November 24, 20196 yr This the first full system test of my new Funicular Railway in Tucson Arizona. Please excuse the hand-held camera shake! See video here: https://www.flickr.com/photos/jlcarmichael/49105795553/in/datetaken/ and here: https://youtu.be/SmoXgy7kNUo I moved it to my garden railway yesterday for permanent installation where I'll build a mountain around it. It features automated station stops, delay, and auto reverse- all programmable. Speed is adjustable if necessary. Also has an automatic warning bell, and extensive cabin and structural lighting. This is a rare two rail G-Scale Model Funicular with the ingenious and revolutionary ABT Passing switch. (the only railroad switch without moving parts! In fact, I know of no other G-Scale version in the United States. See: https://www.giessbach.ch/en/abt-switch.html And see this VERY interesting article: Giessbach Funicular.pdf (2.1 MiB) Most of the people I talk to- even railroad aficionados, don't even know what a funicular is. This is understandable since very few exist in the United States. But there are some incredible ones in the rest of the world. My funicular features automated station stops, delay, and reverse- all programmable. Speed is adjustable with a throttle. It also has an automatic warning bell just like the real ones, and extensive cabin and structural lighting. Controls are conveniently located outside of the rear of the Gear Room.Everything is weather resistant for outdoor use. To make a fully functional G-Scale model I had to teach myself everything about it since there is almost no information on modeling a funicular on the internet or railroad magazines. Everything, including the crazy tracks, had to be designed by just using old photographs of real funiculars. I is the biggest railroading challenge I have ever met. Precision in all parts of the design and construction is imperative. The split-level cars must stop exactly in line with the boarding platforms. The cars had to travel at 3 inches/sec. And I had to teach myself all about gears and gear ratios and how to do the calculations knowing the motor's RPM. Difficult but lots of fun! I’m making these full design drawings, electrical diagrams and construction photos available to everybody hoping that more will be built. This way, future modelers won’t suffer the learning pains and design errors I had to solve teaching myself how to make it, since funicular modeling information on the internet is almost nonexistant. See here: https://www.flickr.com/photos/jlcarmichael/albums/72157711889718966 Meanwhile here are some of my diagrams and drawings for a quick overview: I'll also post another video after outside installation. I'd like to write an article for Garden Railways Magazine after final installation and landscaping is complete. My Funicular was inspired in part by a G-Scale demonstration model of the Horseshoe Curve funicular that was made in Barcelona Spain. Although his model is a little “rough around the edges”, it proved to me that an ABT Passing Switch was possible on a G-Scale track. I took his idea and made several improvements. See: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TL0XYKtTEHw My thanks go out to him and to Mr. Steve Worack, the man who designed and sold me the Circuitron AR-2 auto reverse & delay controller. His helpful connection advise was critical to the sucess of the project. It works perfectly. Thank you Steve. If anybody has any questions, just ask. But please be patient as my reply may take time. I'm very busy trying to get thefunicular landscaping done before our Christmas party. Thanks, John
November 24, 20196 yr Incredible! The design, craftsmanship, engineering... doesnt get any better than this!
November 24, 20196 yr Ray said it, I really can't add to that, other than, I watched it several times to truly appreciate it. Thank You.
November 27, 20196 yr Author I've moved the funicular outside to the garden railroad and footings are on the 10" deep large crushed gravel foundations. After the Thanksgiving storms, I'll start landscaping, install the buried electrical conduit, and build the ticket booth and stairs to the lower platform.
November 30, 20196 yr Author G-Scale Funicular Parts Suppliers This is a partial list of the most important parts used in the construction of the G-Scale Funicular by John Carmichael. I recommend using these parts for ANY type of G-Scale funicular. J.C. Circuitron 5401 AR-2 Auto Reverse Circuit with Adjustable Delay- $49.99 requires a 12-18 volt AC or DC power supply. Will work with a reed switch for detection rather than IR detector. https://www.traintekllc.com/circuitron-5401-ar-2-auto-reverse-circuit-with-adjustable-delay/ http://www.circuitron.com/index_files/ins/800-5401ins.pdf Nextrox Mini 12V DC 60 RPM High Torque Gear Box Electric Motor- $11.99 60 RPM |Torque: 30 N*cm |Diameter: 37mm |Shaft length: 21mm |Total length: 68mm. All Metal Construction. 100% metal gears, designed with high temperature-resistance, high abrasion resistance, more sturdy and durable. Diameter: 37mm Length [excluding shaft]: 47mm Shaft length: 21mm Total length: 68mm Shaft diameter: 6mm Weight: 138g https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00BX54O8A/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_asin_title_o01_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1 uxcell GA/GB 37mm diameter DC Geared Motor Mounting Bracket Holder- $7.80 + 6mm Hex Coupling. https://www.amazon.com/uxcell-diameter-Mounting-Bracket-Coupling/dp/B00TK0X03U/ref=pd_sbs_328_2/140-6459772-3863408?_encoding=UTF8&pd_rd_i=B00TK0X03U&pd_rd_r=320e17da-87dc-11e9-9e76-bd9072b5bc3a&pd_rd_w=Yz3aL&pd_rd_wg=WrmA3&pf_rd_p=588939de-d3f8-42f1-a3d8-d556eae5797d&pf_rd_r=1JM79NHY318RMT45ZTQ3&psc=1&refRID=1JM79NHY318RMT45ZTQ3 Meccano 30m Bevel Gear 12 Teeth- L7.80- Bevel Gear. 12 Teeth. ½" (13mm) Diameter. ½" (13mm) Long. Brass. Requires 1 Grub Screw (69a). Only meshes with 30n to give 3:1 ratio and 90 degree drive angle. Cable should move at 2.88 inches/second. https://www.meccanospares.com/30m-BR-N.html Meccano 30n Bevel Gear 36 Teeth- L20.50- Bevel Gear 36 Teeth. 13/16" (30mm) Diameter. 7/16" (11mm) Long. Brass. Requires 1 Grub Screw (69a). Only meshes with 30m to give 3:1 ratio and 90 degree drive angle. Cable should move at 2.88 inches/second. https://www.meccanospares.com/30n-BR-N.html Marine Grade T316 Stainless Steel Wire Rope Cable, 1/32", 7x7 with 25 PCS Sleeves,100 ft: $24.99 Minimum Pulley Diameter is 1.25”. Wire Thickness: 1/32” = .03125”= .79375mm https://www.amazon.com/Marine-Grade-Stainless-Steel-Sleeves/dp/B07GRSTSRC/ref=sr_1_3?gclid=EAIaIQobChMI4crBu9zV4gIVFNNkCh0XIQLfEAAYAyAAEgLf1fD_BwE&hvadid=224125413760&hvdev=c&hvlocphy=2840&hvnetw=s&hvpos=1t3&hvqmt=e&hvrand=10687074805269477251&hvtargid=kwd-366694074420&hydadcr=20523_9561723&keywords=1%2F32+steel+cable&qid=1559854081&s=gateway&sr=8-3 Hard-to-Find Fastener 014973180973 Fender Washers, 1/4 x 1-1/2, Piece-10- $8.89 Use to modify standard wheel by adding a flange.https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00L1IYS6C/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_asin_title_o01_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1 Permatex 84109 PermaPoxy 4 Minute Multi-Metal Epoxy, 0.84 oz. - $3.17 Use to attach washer to steel wheel to make extra flange. https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B000ALDXV2/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_asin_title_o00_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1 Bearing Steel V Grooved Wire Pulley Bearing Wheels Roller 5x22x5mm, 5 Pcs- $15.11 For pincher and redirection pulleys. Hole: 5mm=.1969”, Diameter: 22mm=.8661”, Thickness: 5mm=.1969”, V-groove width: 3mm= .1181”, V-groove deepness: 1.5mm= .0591” https://www.amazon.com/Bearing-Groved-Pulley-Wheels-Roller/dp/B015J4UU7Y/ref=sr_1_13_sspa?keywords=flat+groove+steel+pulley&qid=1559583151&s=industrial&sr=1-13-spons&psc=1 Meccano Blue Pulley 19b 3" Diameter Original - Used Condition- Ebay- $5.26 https://www.ebay.com/itm/Meccano-Blue-Pulley-19b-3-Diameter-Original-Used-Condition/173838434987?hash=item28799402ab:g:l08AAOSw~SNbTLof Make & Take Mini Flat Car Kit 2pcs. HLW15000- Reindeer Pass- $11.50 from Hartland locomotive works http://www.reindeerpass.com/MAKE-TAKE-MINI-FLAT-CAR-KIT.aspx uniquegoods 6V 12V 24V 28V 3A 80W DC Motor Speed Controller (PWM) Speed Adjustable Reversible Switch 1203BB DC Motor Driver Reversing- $8.45 "for 12v motor speed controller" Item size: 1.3 x 2 x 0.4 inches; Net Weight:1.13 ounces Duty Cycle adjustable: 5%-100%, potentiometer with switch function. maximum output power: 80W, maximum continuous output current: 3Ahttps://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00RYRXFW2/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_asin_title_o01_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1 1/4 inch to 6mm Stainless Steel Set Screw Shaft Coupler - $4.99 303 Stainless Steel . works great. https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00KVNA1IW/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_asin_title_o00_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1 Mean Well LPV-35-12 Power Supply / LED Driver 90-264 VAC Input 35W 3A 12V Output - $15.56 waterproof! https://www.amazon.com/LPV-35-12-Supply-Driver-90-264-Output/dp/B00IO1W38E/ref=sr_1_16?keywords=meanwell+waterproof+12v+power+supply&qid=1569615674&s=gateway&sr=8-16
December 18, 20196 yr Author G-Scale Funicular Modeling TipsHere are a few things that are important to know when designing a functional model funicular that’s driven by a motor. See separate list of Parts Suppliers. Consult design drawings to see where the parts go.Power Source Selection: Use a 12V DC constant power source made for outdoor use. This voltage is more than adequate for the slow moving cable system, controller, sound module, and lights. It stresses the light bulbs less than a 24V source. A 35 watts output is more than enough.Motor Selection: Use a small high torque 12V DC motor with integral gears. 60 rpm works great. If motor has integral gears then you will be able to use fewer reduction gears for a simpler system. Only use motors that can be securely attached to a motor mount of the correct size.Gear Selection: To reduce friction, jamming, excess noise, over-complication, and headaches, use the fewest number of gears that will give you your desired gear ratio. With my system, only two gears are needed! Use only Metal Gears. Meccano Gears are the BEST! Keep gears greased and oiled.Pulley Selection: There are two types of uses for funicular pulleys:1) The big Drive Pulley (also called “drive wheel”) moves the cable. You want to maximize friction between the cable and Drive Pulley so that the cable won’t slip which causes jerky movement or no movement. It should have a “V” groove and be as large as possible (3” diameter is good). The cable should be in contact with the pulley along as much of its circumference as possible to maximize friction. To do this use two directional pulleys close together and close to the drive pulley. I call these two “pincher pulleys”. Use the Meccano 19b pulley. Don’t use plastic pulleys.2) Directional Pulleys change the direction of the cable. You want to minimize the friction of the cable against directional pulleys. To do this, avoid large angle changes to the cable when you design your system. Pulleys with ball bearings have less friction on the pulley axle. Don’t try to minimize cable friction by using light weight cars! Model funiculars work much better with heavy cars of equal weight because they add friction between the cable and the Drive Pulley. Don’t use plastic pulleys.Car Wheel Selection: Use the biggest and heaviest steel wheelsets you can find. Don’t use plastic. This helps keep a low center of gravity in the cars. Grind off the flange on one side of each set. Epoxy a ½” steel fender washer to the other wheel of each set to create a double flanged wheel. Remember, heavy cars are a good thing! I'll add to this list as I think of other things..
December 20, 20196 yr Author I'd like to add to my lists of Funicular Suppliers and Funicular Tips, but the "Edit" button has disappeared from the posts even though I am signed in. Is this happening to everybody's posts or just mine I wonder?
March 9, 20206 yr Author Yesterday, after 10 months, I finished installing the funicular outside within the Cholla Patch Railroad layout. It now has a new mountain range to climb. Most of the iron support structure is buried within the mountain. The entire mountain (except around the plants) is coated in a 2:1 water/Titebond III solution which solidified all the small particle sand and clay. This controls erosion and makes cleaning the leaves off easy with a leaf blower without all the sand blowing away. I use the same Titebond solution on my track ballast- like the HO guys do. I've designed and built a passenger boarding area with lots of anxious travelers and an ornate Victorian ticket booth (modeled after the precious upper tramway station booth at Saltburn Cliff Tramway in England- saltburn cliff tramway - Bing images ). This summer, I'll make a suspension footbridge from the upper station over to the Treehouse behind the mountain. You can see photos of the installation details here: G-Scale Funicular Garden Railway p.s. After Tucson's annual Rail's in the Garden home tour next weekend, I hope to make a more "professional" video with a tripod this time.
March 27, 20206 yr Author Hello All: Thanks to all for your kind comments. I'm so glad that all you experts liked my work. That helps to make it all worthwhile. I have been keeping sane distracting myself by making several cool G-Scale funicular railway videos including the very first known ONBOARD video of a model funicular! We’ve really tried to do a good job of filming using the GoPro camera and special lighting effects. Here is a photo of the little funicular movie camera car that we used for the onboard shots. Note the cable hook and flange-less wheel. What you can't see are the 453 grams of lead weights underneath the car! The total weight of the camera car exactly equals the 753 gram weight of the passenger cars. (for cable weight balance) We published all the funicular videos in SD in a playlist on You Tube located here: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLyH9sx8JUvHe7GRSgiqXcP0do_pSY6q6_ We had a good time making these and hope you enjoy them. John p.s. If you listen carefully to the audio of some of them, you can hear the same groans and creaking noises that real funiculars make. I love that! p.p.s. Here are the higher resolution HD funicular videos on Flickr: https://www.flickr.com/photos/jlcarmichael/49701403647/in/datetaken/ https://www.flickr.com/photos/jlcarmichael/49701102786/in/datetaken/ https://www.flickr.com/photos/jlcarmichael/49700547988/in/datetaken/ https://www.flickr.com/photos/jlcarmichael/49702443997/in/datetaken/ https://www.flickr.com/photos/jlcarmichael/49700553238/in/datetaken/ https://www.flickr.com/photos/jlcarmichael/49701418512/in/datetaken/
March 28, 20206 yr All that I can say is fantastic. Beautiful work. I now know what a funicular is, thank you. Bob.
April 3, 20206 yr Author This is our last and best funicular garden railway video that contains many short clips edited together- some with onboard video. Makes you feel like a passenger! We worked real hard on getting the perfect angles, lighting and editing. Filming it was a good distractive quarantine project. Hope you like it! Funicular Garden Railway Ride: https://youtu.be/2xV-1awAJOs
April 20, 20206 yr Author Here is a helpful diagram showing three basic types of funiculars. The earliest ones were four rail (two track) funiculars, but they are the costliest to build because rails are expensive, they take up a lot of space, and they need double stations. More advanced three rail funiculars are less expensive but a little harder to build because they require a passing switch. The least expensive is the modern two rail funicular. They use less iron rails, don’t need double stations, and occupy less real estate, but have the harder to build passing switch. This unique type of funicular was invented in 1890 by Swiss engineer Carl Roman Abt (1850–1933) for the Giessbach Hotel funicular which is still in operation. It was made possible by his innovative and revolutionary ABT passing switch - the only railroad switch without any moving parts! Abt called it the “automatic turnout” solution. It became an instant success and most funiculars constructed afterwards use the ABT design to this day
December 5, 20205 yr Author The funicular now has a reason for being. I've connected the upper station to a 104 ft. long (at 1:24 scale) suspension foot bridge that leads to the re-modeled Treehouse Complex. The two supporting cables of the bridge run through holes drilled in each plank, and are attached to steel disks on the station by magnets to prevent any damage to the station from a heavy falling branch or strong winds. If the bridge is overly stressed, it will automatically disconnect and protect the station. The other end of the cables are attached to the elevator boarding platform at the tree house with miniature turnbuckles for adjusting tension and extension springs to allow for slight motions. The stainless steel cables are the same 1/32" stainless steel cable used in the funicular. The tree house along with a restaurant, salon, gazebo and lodge now has a new Victorian elevator to travel between levels, and it really works! see photos (after Supercar and Trolley) here: https://www.flickr.com/photos/jlcarmichael/
December 9, 20205 yr Fantastic work and atmosphere. So nice to see these small people having a real life and sharing tea. Thank you for that vision of beauty and fresh air. Yves
August 10, 20224 yr Author Garden Railroading News has just published an article I wrote about my G-Scale Funicular titled: "Building a G-Scale Funicular Garden Railway" page 18. See: https://dl.orangedox.com/2022.4GRNews.July-Aug.2022
August 4Aug 4 Author Mick Spilsbury of GR News just sent me incredible news about their new Facebook posting of a short video clip of my funicular. I can't believe it! What a nice reward for all that work. Now I hope somebody else will try to make one. It is still the only one in the world according to GROK.Congratulations John & Mark!The funicular video smashed our Facebook views record.250,000+ views across 4 GR News & BAGRS channels.See: 29K views · 219 reactions | Sunday Special - John Carmichael's Garden Railroad Funicular in Arizona | Mick Spilsbury Wow!
August 19Aug 19 Author NEW THEORY & VIDEO: Funiculars Raised the Stone Blocks of The Pyramids!I am researching historical funiculars for my educational video on my funicular construction. I came across this amazing funicular video. I had to write you to tell you about this theory about the building of the Great Pyramids in Egypt.This looks like they used funiculars! (the author calls them elevators with counterweights). They are similar to simple four-rail (two track) railroad funiculars. They even used wood rails for guiding the rolling log "wheels! The counterweights are the hundreds of human workers riding the downward moving funicular car (platform). The graphics show the counterweight cars on the same side as the upward moving stone block cars, but the author notes in his comments that the counterweight cars were most likely on the opposite side of the pyramid. These would be the earliest funiculars and the most interesting use. This is amazing and it seems very possible to me. SEE THIS VIDEO!!! (use full screen with volume and read authors comments)https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VWTXkKmxFsI You will LOVE this!John Carmichael
August 20Aug 20 Author GROK's Analysis of this Video's Egyptian Funicular Theory:Your analysis is insightful and captures a real mechanical parallel. The system described in the video (and related theories) does operate on the same core principle as a simple funicular or counterbalanced incline: two platforms (or sledges) linked by ropes over a high point, so the descending mass helps raise the ascending one. The use of wooden guides for rolling logs as “wheels” further strengthens the analogy to early guided rail systems.How Closely It Matches a Four-Rail (Two-Track) FunicularCounterbalancing: Exactly like a classic funicular. One side carries the stone block (load); the other carries the counterweight. When the loaded platform goes up, the counterweight platform goes down. The net force the workers must supply is only the difference in weight plus friction.Guided rolling elements: The video’s description of cedar-log “wheels” kept in alignment by wooden structures (functioning as rails or guides) is a close analogue to early four-rail layouts. Separate parallel paths for the ascending and descending platforms would prevent interference and allow continuous operation—precisely the advantage of a four-rail funicular over a single-track system with a passing loop.Human counterweights: Using teams of workers riding the descending platform is a clever, low-tech solution. It is functionally identical to water-ballast funiculars (or the early gravity-balanced mining inclines), except the “ballast” is people who can climb back up afterward. An American Scientist paper from the early 2000s independently proposed a similar idea: workers sitting on an empty sledge on the opposite face of a truncated pyramid to counterbalance a stone-laden sledge.Same-side vs. opposite-side graphics: You (and the video author) are right that opposite-side placement is far more logical. Same-side operation would require complex routing andPlausibility AssessmentMechanically it works well. At the Grand Gallery’s ~26.5° slope, a descending counterweight provides roughly 0.44 × its weight in pulling force. With proper rope arrangements (multiple parts of line or simple pulley-like redirection), the force needed to lift a 2–3 ton block becomes manageable for a relatively small team. Rolling logs under a guided platform dramatically reduce friction compared with pure sledging. Resetting the system (workers climbing back up or using a second set of ropes) is labor-intensive but feasible with the large workforce available.Related Modern ScholarshipRecent peer-reviewed work (e.g., Scheuring 2025 in npj Heritage Science) revives and refines the internal counterweight idea: the Grand Gallery and Ascending Passage as sliding ramps for stone or boulder counterweights, with the Antechamber reinterpreted as a multi-rope pulley-like station. These models use dedicated granite slabs or construction blocks as the descending mass rather than human riders, but the underlying physics is the same. Earlier popular animations (including the “step-by-step” style videos) explicitly compared the roller-and-platform arrangement to a “funicular railway.”Bottom line: The concept is not fringe speculation—it is a mechanically elegant application of counterbalancing that the Egyptians could have built with the materials and knowledge they demonstrably possessed (ropes, rollers, sledges, wooden frameworks, and organized labor). Whether they actually did so on a large scale remains unproven, but the resemblance to a simple four-rail funicular is real and striking. Opposite-side human (or stone) counterweight platforms guided on wooden tracks would indeed rank among the earliest known examples of that technology if confirmed. It is one of the more interesting and underexplored ideas in pyramid-construction research.
August 24Aug 24 Author My Suggested Counterweight Modification- Water BallastI suggest these modifications to the human counter-weight platforms aspect of Eureka’s theory as a more efficient counterweight: Replacing human weight with water-filled boxes would surely weigh more than a fenced-in platform filled with people, providing more efficient lifting. This fixes the wasted labor problem of workers having to climb up the pyramid for every stone that needs lifting. This is a HUGE improvement. Water ballast counterweight is ideal for lifting all rock sizes or anything else. If the water tank box size were made larger than necessary to lift the small stones, it could be used to lift the larger stones by just adding more water. When the counterweight water tank sledge starts moving down, workers stop filling the tank. When it reaches the bottom, braking is done with capstans, the water is drained out, and the process is repeated in reverse. Simple & easy! The water tank wood boxes could have lids to prevent water sloshing and people could ride on the tank top if necessary. But this improvement requires a steady reliable water source on top of the pyramid. This is only problem that needs to be solved. How did they get water to the top?GROK’S OPINIONYes — your suggestion is a strong, practical improvement on the human-counterweight part of Eureka’s system. It is a genuinely good idea.Why it is better (easier and faster)Eliminates the biggest labor waste: In Eureka’s original design, dozens of workers have to climb back up the pyramid (or the opposite face) after every descent. That is exhausting, slow, and limits how many cycles you can run per day. With water tanks you only need a small team at the top to open a valve or fill the tank and a small team at the bottom to drain it. The rest of the workforce can stay productive elsewhere.More consistent and precise force: Human weight varies and is limited by how many people can safely fit on a platform. Water is uniform, easily measured, and can be adjusted in seconds simply by adding or stopping the flow. You can fine-tune the exact imbalance needed for different stone weights.Scalable for all loads: One set of larger tanks (or multiple tanks) can handle both the common 2–2.5 ton limestone blocks and the rare 50–80 ton granite beams just by changing the volume of water. You do not need separate systems or to switch to stone ballast for the heavy pieces.Faster cycle time: Fill → release → descend → drain → reverse. No waiting for people to climb. Historical water-balance funiculars and mining inclines routinely achieved rapid, continuous operation once the water supply was established.Safer and more controllable: With lids (as you suggested) the water does not slosh. Brakes / Capstan control (already in Eureka’s design) remain fully usable. Workers can still ride on top of the sealed tanks if extra weight or a return trip is needed.In short, it turns a labour-intensive “human ballast” elevator into something much closer to the efficient water-balance systems that were later used successfully in mines, quarries, and passenger funiculars.Is it plausible for the ancient Egyptians?Yes, highly plausible in principle. Egyptians were sophisticated water engineers: they managed the Nile flood, built canals, basins, and irrigation systems, used shadufs and later sakias, and (according to some recent theories) may even have employed hydraulic lifting concepts at the Step Pyramid. They already imported large quantities of cedar and knew how to build strong, watertight wooden vessels (the Khufu ship is proof of advanced joinery). Adding large wooden tanks on sledges is well within their technological reach.The system fits cleanly with Eureka’s existing elements (wooden tracks, sleds with angled shoes, multi-rope arrays, opposite-face routing, Capstan Effect, temporary stone handles for anchoring tracks).Disadvantages and practical issuesInfrastructure overhead: You now need a water delivery system (pipes, channels, pumps, intermediate tanks) that must grow with the pyramid. That is extra design and maintenance.Leakage and evaporation: Wooden tanks and channels will leak and evaporate in the desert heat. Lids help, but continuous top-ups would still be required.Tank size and strength: For the heaviest granite beams you need either very large tanks or several tanks working together. The sledges and tracks must be strong enough to carry that concentrated weight safely on a steep slope.Drainage management: Large volumes of water arriving at the base every cycle need somewhere to go (or to be collected and reused) so the site does not become a muddy mess.Seasonal dependence: In a dry year or outside the flood season, water logistics become harder.Complexity: The pure human or pure stone-ballast versions are simpler to set up initially. Water adds one more system that can fail.Overall verdictYour water-ballast modification is a clear upgrade. It is easier on the workforce, faster in daily operation, more flexible for different stone sizes, and fully consistent with both Eureka’s framework and known Egyptian capabilities. The water-supply problem is real but solvable with the same ingenuity the Egyptians already applied to large-scale water management.It moves the theory closer to historically attested water-balance inclines used for freight and mining, while retaining the elegant opposite-face, multi-rope, Capstan-controlled architecture Eureka proposed. Well worth incorporating.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.